Skip Navigation

Sydney's next Archbishop and a crisis in leadership

Thu 13 June 2013

Sydney's next Archbishop and a crisis in leadership

Our Church needs urgent prayer. With the Royal Commission into child sexual abuse looming, the Anglican Church in NSW is facing a growing crisis in leadership.

The list begins with the Archbishop of Sydney. Dr Peter Jensen will be farewelled tomorrow (Friday, June 14), and the election of the next Metropolitan of NSW will certainly grab the media headlines. But the core of the problem lies elsewhere. In recent months both Newcastle and Riverina Dioceses have failed to elect bishops. And in the most telling omen, the Bishop of Grafton resigned last month over his handling of sexual abuse allegations.

Meanwhile Rick Lewers in Armidale has just clocked his one year anniversary, while you can count on one hand the months since Ian Palmer was consecrated in Bathurst. Just four years after his appointment, our own Bishop Stuart Robinson is by far the most experienced diocesan bishop in the Province. Given the above context, please pray for him. 

The burden of leadership at the moment is overwhelming for our diocesans. I am well aware of bishops that have quietly stepped down out of spiritual and emotional exhaustion from dealing with professional standards matters.

I hope the candidates for Archbishop of Sydney, especially in their role as Metropolitan of NSW, understand what they will be forced to confront over the next few years.

Sydney’s next Archbishop 

As the ABC has reported, two candidates have been nominated as Metropolitan - the Bishop of North Sydney, Dr Glenn Davies, and the rector of Naremburn-Cammeray Anglican Church, Rick Smith. An energetic and open social media battle is being waged by supporters. Its "GlennDavies.info" v "WhyRick"

It would be foolish for someone outside Sydney Diocese to back either candidate. I am sure any endorsement would be read by those in the Harbour city as the kiss of death!

Rick Smith’s chances should not be under-estimated. In fact reading the high level endorsements it is clear he is actually in pole position, and the election is his to lose. Rick is the candidate openly backed by the influential Dean of Sydney, Phillip Jensen who is hosting private meet and greet sessions for electors. But more importantly Rick is being presented and increasingly perceived as the “mission” candidate and that counts for everything in Sydney. Whether this is truly fair to Bishop Davies and his oversight of church planting within Sydney’s northern region is another matter.

Earlier this week, Tony Payne from Matthias Media published some insights into the Sydney Anglican mindset when it comes to electing their next leader. Tony’s column gives a fair overview of the arguments being run for each candidate, all be it clearly stating his bias towards Rick.

But what does the election mean for those of us outside Sydney Diocese? On one level not much. Both men are thoroughly conservative Reformed evangelicals. Their policies would be identical on the touchstone issues that divide Australian Anglicans such as the ordination of women as priests. The personal style of Rick Smith leans towards ministry-minded pragmatism. So I would expect that in the long run this will result in similar moderate outcomes in their approach to Anglican politics. Five years down the track Rick Smith will be his own man, and the ghostly guiding hand of Phillip Jensen will have long faded. 

Reflections on wider implications of election campaign 

To say our rural NSW Dioceses are struggling on numerous fronts would be an understatement. There are real questions around the viability of a number of the rural Dioceses. Indeed, two NSW Dioceses are currently receiving financial oversight from General Synod. The notion that our Metropolitan Diocese can cruise along responsibility-free is naïve to say the least.

It was a growing awareness of these problems, and the leadership role Sydney Diocese may be ultimately forced to play, that framed Archbishop Jensen's involvement in the Mission Convention held in Canberra last year. The Convention could have been a turning point in relations within the Province. But the opportunity was missed, partially because Dr Jensen's retirement loomed.

If the tone of Archbishop’s election is any guide the Sydney leadership are about to hit the reset button on the Iron Curtain between us. And in the light of the Royal Commission, amongst other issues, that is very troubling.

This is especially reflected in the “Why Rick?” campaign being run by Dominic Steele and Chris Braga as they try to reposition Bishop Glenn Davies’ long experience working with other Anglican Dioceses as a negative. They are promoting Rick Smith as the best leader to maintain a confrontational and antagonistic relationship with the National Church. The following text is currently highlighted on the campaign home page and was released as an email on June 3, titled The Principals speak: Woodhouse and Thompson on Why Rick is the man to lead the Diocese.

Dr Thompson, who will take up his appointment as Principal of Moore College this Thursday, says Mr Smith will be able to represent the Sydney Diocese well as we negotiate our sometimes complicated relationship with the National Church. 

Dr Thompson, Mr Smith and other leaders from Sydney are just back from several days of negotiation with a group from the National Church's General Synod about major issues of difference.

 

Like the boy in the bubble, some Sydney Anglicans want to live in protective plastic-wrap of their own construction. The aim is to keep the impurities of the wider Christian world on the outside. But this bubble is about to burst.     

The general public believes the Archbishop of Sydney leads the church in NSW and the buck stops with him. This perception will frame discussion around the Royal Commission, and that perception is not entirely misplaced. The fact is that we have structures, like Provincial Synod, that clearly tie us together. Our problems will become his problems.

It is high time Sydney Anglicans, like those running Rick Smith's election campaign, woke up and realised that their campaign rhetoric is built on the tired, old Anglican politics of last century.

The hardest challenges confronting the next Archbishop of Sydney are the ones we all share.

By Jeremy Halcrow

Comment on this article


< Back

Comments

thanks Jeremy for your challenging and thoughtful article

I've been asked to explain in more detail the financial issues. It is on the public record that the Diocese of Bathurst has $40m in debts to repay and is selling two of its schools in Dubbo and Orange. Addressing the problems in Bathurst and Grafton will take the co-operation of all the NSW Dioceses. So we need an Archbishop who has the skill set required to work productively with others.

You are concerned about Sydney's relationship with the rest of Australia but publish an article like this.

This just perpetuates the usual uninformed bias against Sydney within the Australian Anglican denomination.

Your boy in the plastic bubble reference is inaccurate and simplistic. It doesn't consider the reasons why Sydney has had a complicated relationship with the Australian denomination. Nor does it consider Sydney's involvement in the wider communion through GAFCON, Work Outside the Diocese, Moore College correspondence courses and much more.

Thanks for your comment Gav. Its genuinely encouraging to have the President of the Anglican Church League and one of the key backers of Rick Smith engage with the point I'm trying to make. What we want to hear from Rick's campaign is to what extent he has the skills, experience and aptitude to lead the Anglican Church in NSW. He will be Metropolitan, and with that comes obligations and responsibilities that his campaign doesn't seem to have considered. My comment was aimed at the line of argument that Dominic Steele and Chris Braga have been promoting and now you have repeated. To be honest it troubles me that you think that taking a tough line during theological disputes is the end of the matter. Rick's campaign needs to engage with the real bigger picture a little more. For example, how is Rick going to represent us all at the Royal Commission when they interogate him on ministers who have moved from Diocese to Diocese? He can't tell the Royal Commission I have never talked to the leadership in x Diocese because I don't agree with their theological position on y. The situation in some of the NSW rural Dioceses is dire. With a little more openness to the idea of cooperation, the Archbishop of Sydney could be a catalyst for mission and growth across the Province of NSW. Isn't that his primary task at the end of the day?

I think you'll find Jeremy is pretty well informed, Gavin!

Rick has been involved on a General Synod Consultation Committee since 2009. He has also been in conversation with the General Synod Unity Task Force (as has Glenn Davies) and the General Synod Financial Policies Task Force. Both the Sydney diocese and the General Synod are making a fair attempt to improve the situation. Time and resources have been ploughed into it. The tone has been both confrontational and cooperative. It has to be.

It is impossible to know what will be asked of the Metropolitan in the future or how he will respond. We can only judge on his past performance. Rick has demonstrated wisdom and gospel focus to date. We hope and pray, if elected, he will do so in the future.

But comments and expressed opinions like yours won't help.

Gavin, maybe I could have been more irenic in the metaphor I used. To be honest I was upset by the way your election material framed the relationship between Sydney and Anglicans elsewhere. I am the last person who wants to stereotype Sydney Anglicans and I certainly have no desire to comment on the capacities of the respective candidates. That said, I think it fair to say the election material merely framed the relationship between Sydney and other Dioceses as one of opposition and confrontation and did not consider the possibility of cooperation with mission-minded Anglicans elsewhere for the sake of Kingdom growth.

Dear Jeremy,

I hope you are well and are enjoying Canberra. I was surprised to read that I was "promoting Rick Smith as the best leader to maintain a confrontational and antagonistic relationship with the National Church." I am sorry that you gained that impression as that hasn't been Rick's tone whenever I have spoken with him on this subject.

For an example of his approach go to www.whyrick.info/questions and scroll down to the question "Does Rick have a vision for the province of NSW & ACT? How does he see that playing out?" His short answer given at a meeting of synod reps was in part: 'My approach would be not to go in with an agenda other than to be concerned with their welfare and to love them.'

Warmly, Dominic

Latest Positions Vacant

  • CHURCH OF ST ANDREW, FORREST - MINISTRY ASSISTANT

    Are you an experienced Assistant with a background in Office Management?
    Working Environment
    The Church of St Andrew Canberra has a unique identity as a Christian Church in the ACT and aims to develop a Christian Environment to serve the Canberra Community.
    Your new role with in your new position you will provide administrative support to the Senior Minister and ministry team and manage the church office, mainly preparation of papers and publications. Working in a sensitive area of pastoral need you will be called on to assist with, assess and refer pastoral issues.

    What you'll need to succeed
    Demonstrated Christian commitment and previous experience working as a personal assistant and office manager with pastoral care understanding or a willingness to train.

    What you'll get in return
    The position comes with an attractive salary and employment package and opportunity to grow, with training opportunities.

    What you need to do now
    If you're interested in this role please contact David Buchanan, Deputy Clerk Church of St Andrew Canberra, to request application advice and position description.
    dbuchanan@netspeed.com.au
    Ph: 0450 96 20 82
    Position Description can be found on the Church’s website
    www.standrewscanberra.com
    Closing date for applications 13 February 2016

  • THERAPEUTIC SERVICES MANAGER Fixed Term – 12 Months

    Are you passionate about Out of Home Care (OOHC), therapeutic care models and providing the best outcomes for children and young people and their families?

    The Therapeutic Services Manager is an exciting new position within Anglicare which will provide expert leadership in the provision of high quality therapeutic services for children, young people, their families and carers, within Anglicare’s OOHC programs across NSW.

    Anglicare is a major community services provider across many locations in regional NSW as well as in the ACT, so this position will be based in Holt in the ACT but require regular travel to our NSW service locations.

    Salary package:
    Salary $100K+ negotiable, (total package also includes car and PBI benefits)

    We offer above award remuneration and generous salary sacrifice options are available under Anglicare's PBI status.

    Full-time – 76 hours per fortnight, initially for 12 months. Based at the ACT Holt office with regular travel to our regional offices in NSW.

    Applicants must obtain a Working With Children’s Check through the NSW Office of the Children’s Guardian and undergo a National Criminal History Check. Prior to any appointment applicants are required to undertake the psychometric profiling instrument – SafeSelect TM.

    The position description, including the selection criteria can be obtained from Anglicare’s website www.anglicare.com.au. For prospective employees, further information about Anglicare can be found by reading through the Online Induction package also found on our website.


    If you have any questions in relation to this position please contact
    Ann Ponsonby on (02) 6245 7148 or email ann.ponsonby@anglicare.com.au.

    If you have high level skills and experience in providing therapeutic services for children, young people and their families
    and are passionate about high quality services for children and young people in OOHC, then please send your
    resume and application addressing the criteria and key knowledge areas to Clare Thomas at:
    clare.thomas@anglicare.com.au

    by COB Monday 15th February 2016

  • Quality Standards Support Officer Part-time – WAGGA WAGGA

    Based in Wagga Wagga. Part-time – 24 hours per week - Fixed Term Contact until December 2016.

    An exciting position exists for a Quality Standards Support Officer working across portfolios within Anglicare NSW South, NSW West & ACT.

    The successful applicant will support and promote best practice and consistency across Community Service Programs through monitoring and implementation of standards. The role will assist in the planning and implementation of project plans and participate in internal audit activities and preparation for accreditation.

    The successful applicant will have a minimum of three years practical experience in Community Services along with formal qualifications.

    A generous remuneration package is offered with salary packaging options available under Anglicare’s PBI status.

    Applicants must obtain a Working with Children clearance through the Office of the Children’s Guardian (NSW) and undergo a National Criminal History Check prior to an offer of employment.

    Prior to appointment, the successful applicant will be required to undertake the psychometric profiling instrument – SafeSelect TM.

    The Position Description, including selection criteria can be obtained from Anglicare’s website www.anglicare.com.au

    For any enquiries, please contact Carmel Swan, Quality Standards Manager on 0438837887

    Written applications addressing the key requirements of the position along with a comprehensive resume and details of two work referees are to be submitted to carmel.swan@anglicare.com.au by close of business Wednesday 17th February 2016.

  • EXECUTIVE ASSISTANT PART TIME - ANGLICARE

    Anglicare is a major community services provider across regional NSW and the ACT. We are seeking some-one who is interested in social justice and improving the lives of vulnerable people to join Anglicare’s Central Office team as a part time Executive Assistant.

    The position will provide administrative support to the CEO as well as some members of the Senior Management Team and be responsible for all aspects of general office management.

    The position is part time – negotiable between 2-3 days per week. Applicants must have prior administrative experience, well developed written and oral communication skills; a good knowledge of administrative procedures and a valid driver’s license. The salary includes generous salary sacrifice options available under Anglicare’s PBI status.

    Prior to interview, shortlisted applicants will be required to undertake the psychometric profiling instrument – SafeSelect ™.

    The position description, including the selection criteria can be obtained from Anglicare’s website www.anglicare.com.au. For prospective employees, further information about Anglicare can be found by reading through the Online Induction package also found on our website.


    If you have any questions in relation to this position please contact Ann Ponsonby on (02) 6245 7148.

    If you have had experience in a similar role and would like to apply for this position, please send your resume and application
    addressing the criteria and key knowledge areas to: ann.ponsonby@anglicare.com.au.

    Applications close Friday 19th February 2016.

  • Youth Workers – Residential Care - Sydney Casual positions

    St Saviours is an organization committed to professional service and delivering therapeutic care to see positive outcomes and achieve better results for the young people in our care. We are seeking professional individuals who are interested in joining our team as a “Casual Youth Worker” with the opportunity of Permanent Part-time positions.

    Primary Responsibility:
    To work with our Residential Care Teams supporting vulnerable young people who have experienced trauma and abuse through 24hour support programs. As part of the Residential Care Team you will be required to work with the young people to help build strength and to grow their resilience.
    This role desires the successful applicants, to work closely with Residential Care Teams planning and facilitating options based on the individual “young person’s” needs, through education, recreational activities, case planning and individual life skills. You will be able to support our young people with guidance including case management and advocacy as well as liaising with internal and external service providers.
    Key Selection Criteria
    · Tertiary qualifications in social work, community services or youth work minimum qualification Cert 3.
    · Minimum 2 years experience in successful coaching and mentoring young people in a Residential Care Service.
    · A sound knowledge of the stages of child and adolescent development along with interpersonal skills relating to behaviours exhibited in the context of past trauma and abuse.
    · Proven ability to respond to youth issues, knowledge and understanding of case management principles and experience in case work provision.
    · Excellent communication and interpersonal skills, demonstrating confidence in engaging young people with complex needs from a range of cultural and socio-economic backgrounds.
    · Ability to work in both a team environment and work independently.
    · A current full driver's license.
    · Must hold current Working with Children’s Check and undergo Criminal History Background check prior to appointment.
    · Must hold Valid First Aid Certificate or be willing to obtain.
    This is a great opportunity to join our passionate team at St Saviours who provide ongoing accredited training, development opportunities and clinical support to all staff.

    The Position Description, including selection criteria can be obtained from Anglicare’s website www.anglicare.com.au

    For all enquiries, please contact Bronson Faitau on 0408033475 or email bronson.faitau@anglicare.com.au.

    To apply, please submit applications to stsaviours.recruitment@stsaviours.org.au

    Applications close Friday 19th February, 2016

  • NATURE BASED EDUCATIONAL LEADER Calwell and Gordon Early Childhood Centres

    We require an Educational Leader to transform the pedagogical understanding and practice at Calwell and Gordon Early Childhood Centres. This is a full-time, noncontact position shared across the two centres. We are looking for someone who is passionate about nature based education and who likes dancing in the rain and looking for fairies under the trees.

    We see children as capable, competent and imaginative explorers who are able to drive their own learning through extended periods of uninterrupted play. We encourage the use of natural materials and loose parts to support children to facilitate their own learning.

    We use Talking and Thinking Floorbooks as a meaningful form of documenting children’s voices and learning. We believe in developing a community of learning and belonging for everyone and we strive for excellence under the National Quality Standards.

    If you have what it takes to engage children in a world of awe and wonder we are looking for you!

    Applicants will be highly motivated, innovative and be able to drive quality practices and programs. Previous experience in long day care is essential. Applicants must have a thorough working knowledge of the National Quality Standards and Early Years Learning Framework.

    We offer above award pay and conditions including generous salary sacrifice benefits are available under Anglicare’s PBI status.

    Applicants must obtain a Working With Vulnerable People clearance through the Office of Regulatory Services (ACT) and undergo a National Criminal History Check prior to an offer of employment.

    As part of the recruitment process, applicants will be required to undertake the psychometric profiling instrument – SafeSelect TM.


    The Position Description, including selection criteria can be obtained from Anglicare’s website www.anglicare.com.au

    For all enquiries, please contact Bec on (02) 6291 4396 or Jess on (02) 6294 7377.

    To apply, please forward your resume to either rebecca.burgess@anglicare.com.au or jessica.kelly@anglicare.com.au

    Applications close Monday 15th February 2016.

  • CASE MANAGER (Out of Home Care- Aboriginal) WAGGA WAGGA (Full Time)

    The Wanggaay Koori Out-of-Home Care Service is a partnership between Anglicare and Riverina Medical and Dental (RIVMED). This service provides culturally appropriate Out-of-Home Care case management to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander children, young people and their carers.

    We are looking for a competent, professional individual to join our expanding team. As a Case Manager, you will develop and implement case plans for children and young people in Out-of-Home Care. You will work with families, foster carers and other professionals to achieve the best outcomes for kids in care.

    The successful applicant will have experience working with kids with high support needs, demonstrated competencies in assessment and case management and excellent report writing skills. Tertiary qualifications and or relevant experience in a human services setting will also be essential

    Applications are sought form Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander People pursuant to Section 14 of the Anti Discrimination Act 1977 NSW.

    Generous salary sacrifice benefits available under Anglicare’s PBI status.

    Prior to interview, shortlisted applicants will be required to undertake the psychometric profiling instrument – SafeSelect TM.

    The successful applicant will be required to provide a current Working with Children’s Check clearance number for verification.

    Please contact Carol Stevens on 69371555 or email carol.stevens@anglicare.com.au to obtain an information pack.

    Applications addressing the section criteria can be emailed to Tangerene Ingram at tangerine.ingram@anglicare.cpm.au by close of business Wednesday 24th February 2016.

  • CASE MANAGEMENT COORDINATOR Full time Position ALBURY

    Anglicare Riverina’s Out of Home Care (OOHC) Services provide a safe and nurturing environment for children and young people not able to live with their birth family.

    We are seeking a qualified, experienced, flexible and self-motivated person to lead our OOHC team. Located in Albury, this position is responsible for the support and supervision of a team of case managers and ensuring quality services for young people, their foster carers and birth families.

    The successful applicant will also have strong interpersonal and networking skills, excellent report writing skills and the ability to lead and work collaboratively as part of a team.

    A working knowledge of the OOHC sector in NSW and all relevant legislation is essential for this role and experience in the coordination of Out of Home Care Services for young people is desirable.

    Tertiary qualifications in a human services setting is essential, as well as a current drivers licence.

    Generous salary sacrifice options are available under Anglicare’s PBI status.

    Applicants must obtain a Working with Children clearance through the Office of the Children’s Guardian (NSW) and undergo a National Criminal History Check prior to an offer of employment.

    Prior to appointment, the successful applicant will be required to undertake the psychometric profiling instrument – SafeSelect TM.


    The Position Description, including selection criteria can be obtained from Anglicare’s website www.anglicare.com.au.

    To find out more about this position and to obtain an Information Pack, please contact Carol Stevens on (02) 6937 1555 or email carol.stevens@anglicare.com.au.

    Applications including a resume and cover letter addressing the key requirements of the position can be forwarded to Serena Griggs, OOHC Manager Anglicare Riverina at serena.griggs@anglicare.com.au

    Applications Close: COB 29 February 2016.

Our Partner dioceses

Starting Mission Shaped Churches